National Pain Conference in Hobart – Implications for Workers Compensation Systems

APS

I had the pleasure over the last 3 days to attend the national conference of the Australian Pain Society. Luckily for me it was held in Hobart, just a stone’s throw from my practice on the outskirts of the Hobart CBD – everything is close in Hobart.

Source: Dr Peter Sharman –  National Pain Conference in Hobart – Implications for Workers Compensation Systems

I thought it might be useful to provide a summary of what was relevant to my practice as an occupational physician, in particular what information might be helpful to doctors and workers stuck within the worker’s compensation system.

The theme of the conference was Personalised Pain Management – Quest for the Holy Grail’  i.e. what progress has been made in developing strategies that work for individuals to manage persistent/chronic pain. There were keynote speakers from the UK, Canada and USA as well as a variety of renowned Australian experts.

Professor Mogil from Canada presented the Sunderland Lecture on ‘The nature and nurture of pain’  i.e. the influence from both an individual’s genetic makeup and their environment on the genesis of persistent pain. He emphasised the genetic basis for the variability  i.e. different genes affect our susceptibility to the development of persistent pain. Understanding how genes influence pain can help elucidate mechanisms of chronic pain and identify targets to develop new medications and other treatments to control pain. While this holds promise for the future it is a difficult and complex area that at present doesn’t help a clinician, except to the extent that is provides an explanation as to why there are differing responses to injury in individuals.

What is clear is that the phenomenon of persistent pain has its genesis in neuroplasticity’   i.e. changes at a neuronal and molecular level within the nervous system that result in persisting pain that continues after the original injury has resolved. These changes can occur at the periphery or centrally within the nervous system, at the level of the spinal cord and within the brain itself. The environment of the individual affects these processes and this is where psychological factors and stress are so important.

As a practicing physician my interest is focused on what can be done for an individual patient to assist with recovery and regaining of function following injury and how that translates into action to improve processes at a system level. I was particularly interested in the conference sessions that related to the subgroup of people within the workers compensation system.

The session on the afternoon of the first day entitled Personalised pain management within a multidisciplinary persistent pain program’ was of particular interest. The session included presentations by Professor Michael Nicholas from NSW and Ms Sara Brentnall and Mr Paul Beaton, both from Victoria.

Professor Nicholas emphasised the importance of the patient having their own achievable goals and understanding of the treatment to improve the outcomes. Personalised treatment for chronic pain is vital. His programs include injured workers within compensation systems.

Sara Brentnall presented a perspective from Austin Health in Victoria.  Again in that programme there was emphasis on ‘One Size Doesn’t Fit All’  i.e. individualised programmes. The presentation by Paul Beaton from Eastern Health was the most interesting. Not only was the presentation innovative with amazing graphics, but the programme itself was based on the bio-psycho-social model emphasising the need for multidisciplinary input ‘in collaborative partnerships with those in pain’. The emphasis was on ‘active’ self management with personalised care. ‘The Pain Storm’ concept was presented providing a basis for individuals to understand the factors contributing to their own ‘Pain Storm’ with an integrated array of physical, psychological, medical  and social strategies to put the person with pain in control with the prospect of lasting change in understanding, attitude, skills and environment and more engagement in meaningful life activities.

Interestingly the Victorian programmes referred to above do not include workers compensation patients on the basis that WorkSafe Victoria has a network of practitioners that provide a similar service.

Unfortunately the workers compensation system is a potent factor in taking away an individual’s sense of control and imposing a ‘one size fits all’  approach to the management of persistent pain. It is unsurprising that workers compensation patients have a higher incidence of chronic pain and overall do worse than other types of patients.

The session on ‘Entrapment Neuropathies’  e.g.  carpal tunnel syndrome by Professor Michel Coppieters provided some insights. There is increasing understanding of the changes both at the level of entrapment and centrally within the nervous system from animal models. These changes can explain the variable clinical presentation of these disorders and why they do always present as described in textbooks nor always respond to traditional treatments like decompression surgery. Again this provided insight and understanding about why some conditions are difficult to manage, but little practical guidance on how to achieve better results, except that nerve mobilisation may have a greater role to play.

I did have difficulty accepting some of the conclusions of Professor Chris Maher in his presentation ‘Diagnosis and treatment based classification of back pain’ . I accept that his analysis that the traditional  ‘Red Flags’ used to distinguish serious spine disorders, need revisiting, but I have some difficulty with his conclusion that we are stuck with labelling back pain as ‘non-specific’ on the basis that discal, sacro-iliac and facet joint pain cannot be distinguished clinically or with investigations, including MRI scanning. While it might not be so important to distinguish differing diagnostic entities in a primary care setting in the early stages following injury, I still believe in the specialist management of persistent back pain that it is useful to distinguish these entities while not neglecting management of psycho-social risk factors.

I found a subsequent presentation by Professor Maher very interesting and useful. The presentation ‘What triggers an episode of back pain’  presented new evidence from a study that indicates that not only are the traditional factors in back injury relevant (heavy loads, awkward posture etc) but that being distracted during an activity/task and being fatigued markedly increases the risk of triggering back pain. This makes a great deal of sense to me.

Another matter of interest to patients with CRPS/causalgia/RSD is that the University of NSW  is seeking volunteers with this condition affecting their shoulder/neck/wrist/hand mainly on one side, aged from 18-89 years for MRI studies in Sydney to investigate the role of the brain in CRPS. Interested people could contact Ms Audrey Wang [02] 93991806 or a.wang@neura.edu.au.

In summary, attending the conference reinforces in my mind, that persistent pain is a difficult ‘beast’. The increasing knowledge about neuroplasticity, particularly the process of  ‘central sensitisation’ and the interplay of genetics, a stressful environment and psychological factors can explain the spectrum of disability seen after work-related injury, but at this stage doesn’t provide a solution for everyone. Injured workers with persistent pain need equitable access to effective multidisciplinary programmes for persistent pain.

It becomes less and less surprising to me that workers compensation systems that take away control, impose additional stresses and fail to recognise the need for individualised treatment programmes contribute to poor outcomes for those with the misfortune to be injured at work. Workers compensation systems need to incorporate processes to stratify people with greater needs into care systems that can adequately deal with those needs without imposing unnecessary additional stressors on them.

Read Here: http://workcoverobservertas.wordpress.com/2014/04/17/national-pain-conference-in-hobart-implications-for-workers-compensation-systems/